Students in pubic schools do not write well, as I previously noted (see Part I). Writing instruction in schools is usually provided by teachers who lack writing fluency and typically instruct students to use writing strategies not used by fluent writers. The most important lesson about writing is never taught: that writing is rewriting. Neither do students write enough to become better writers nor do teachers provide specific feedback (or enough feedback) before students write a revision, an infrequen
t activity. Rewriting or revising is mentioned only once among the 10 Common Core Writing Standards (Standard 5).
The new Common Core Standards (CCS) complicates writing instruction because its principal focus is neither writing nor rewriting. Moreover, writing instruction becomes two steps: Learning new content plus writing a paper using new knowledge. CCS for writing and reading for children through Grade 5 requires an overemphasis on reading informational nonfiction (e.g., the arts, history, social studies, sciences, literary content), a practice that continues for students in Grades 6-12. The need to acquire new acknowledge as a prerequisite for writing also complicates improving students’ writing. Students can more easily write about what they know about or a topic they can easily learn about. CCS-based writing, however, often requires students to cope with a new, unfamiliar content before writing papers, a practice that ignores well-established research findings about how language is acquired and how humans learn. And accurately, carefully, and slowly processing language makes comprehension impossible, instruction endorsed by CCS:
The Common Core emphasizes using evidence from texts to present careful [emphasis added] analyses, well-defended claims, and clear information. Rather than asking students questions they can answer solely from their prior knowledge and experience, the standards call for students to answer questions that depend on their having read the texts with care [emphasis added]. The reading standards focus on students’ ability to read carefully [emphasis added] and grasp information, arguments, ideas, and details based on evidence in the text. Students should be able to answer a range of text-dependent questions, whose answers require inferences based on careful [emphasis added] attention to the text (Common Core Standards, 2015).
Acquiring new content requires a good deal of prior knowledge about it to acquire any new information about a topic (Bormuth, 1975), a concept minimized in CCS. Content learned by reading can occur only when readers process print rapidly. To use unfamiliar content as the basis for improving reading or writing fluency will fail because of the student’s lack of prior knowledge, which slows information processing and markedly increases the difficulty in learning to write more fluently. The content will not be learned because the student cannot read fast enough to comprehend, and reading a new content slowly prevents practicing reading’s most important skill: rapid reading, accomplished by minimizing the use of print and maximizing the use of prior knowledge. Neither is writing fluently acquired by writing about unfamiliar subjects, which further slows writing, an inherently slow process, thus interfering with writing and learning to write.
Nationally, CSS are not well-implemented in reading or math, but particularly in math: The content of textbooks is generally not aligned with CSS. The textbooks of 17 of 20 (85%) recently reviewed math programs were found not aligned to CSS (EdReports, 2015). Do not be surprised next year when students do not score well on California’s new state tests.