On tonight’s council agenda – Item 22 on the consent calendar – is a proposal to ban smoking in Anaheim’s public parks. It would also change the municipal code definition of a public park (I sent an inquiry to the city asking which city facilities aren’t currently considered public parks but would be under the proposed re-definition).
Smoking is a nasty, smelly, unhealthy activity. I’ve never smoked a cigarette. I don’t like being nearby when they’re being smoked. But I wouldn’t pass a law to prevent a person from enjoying a cigarette in a park, out in the open air.
Unsurprisingly, the staff report relies the second-hand smoke bogeyman as the primary rationale for the ban:
Municipalities who have enacted smoking bans in parks have cited positive health benefits such as the elimination of second hand smoke, which has been identified as a toxic air contaminant by the California Air Resources Board based on a study they conducted in 2005. In addition of the reduction of second hand smoke in parks, many cities have cited the reduction of litter associated with discarded cigarette butts in park settings where smoking was once permitted. An added benefit also cited by various cities that have banned smoking in parks is the positive health example that is set by encouraging people to recreate in a smoke-free environment such as a public park.
It’s one thing to city second-hand smoking when prohibiting smoking in enclosed confines of a city building. But outside? In the open air, unconfined spaces of a city park? This is weak sauce, and unconvincing as an argument to prohibit a legal activity.
As for the anti-littering rational: why pick smoking, as opposed to the many other park activities that also generate litter? Why not ban eating candy in city parks? Candy consumption contributes to the health crisis du jour, obesity. Wouldn’t banning it in parks reduce the litter associated with eating candy and set a positive health example by encouraging people to recreate in an obesity-conscious environment?
The ordinance exempts city-owned golf courses. Why? The supposed public health and litter problems are equally present on the links as at a city park. At the end of the day, both are really big lawns.
Furthermore, prohibitions require enforcement. Does the city have the will and resources to play anti-smoking cop?
During Mayor Curt Pringle’s tenure in office, Anaheim cultivated a culture of freedom-friendly government. Issues like this proposed ban on smoking in city parks may be small potatoes in the scheme of things, but they can also be expressions of the governing ethos. Does Anaheim city government want to remain freedom-friendly, or emulate more “progressive” municipalities by embracing small-bore nanny-state proposals such as this ban?

West Anaheim wants it because it’s another way to keep the homeless out of the parks. This was raised at a meeting in West Anaheim when Councilman Vanderbilt was speaking with residents and he said he would consider taking this step to help residents in our area. He is making good on that commitment.
If that is the reason, it ought to have been stated in the staff report, rather than the phony-baloney health and litter rationales.
But it is still bad public policy.
The world is coming to an end, I agree with Matt Cunningham and oppose James Vanderbilt on an issue.
West Anaheim, the best way to get the homeless out of the parks is to support a homeless shelter. Yet when someone suggested using the Sinkin’ Lincoln site for a shelter, the howls from those in Council Chambers could rival a beagle. BTW-I checked the stats on homeless populations, and prior to the La Palma Dog park “solution” Lucille Kring was cheering, the point-in-time count of our homeless population showed no significant population at Twila Reid Park. So I guess Kring’s “solution” didn’t really solve anything, just moved folks from one place to another. Send your thank you notes to Lucille Kring c/o City Hall at…
Back to Cunningham, I agree, I missed that on my first reado f the Agenda, and I was horrified when I saw that (keep in mind smoking at Anaheim Stadium was dumped ages ago, back in the days of Miriam Kaywood) but the whole thing is a JOKE because at the bottom of the staff report it says No impact to the General Fund” meaning they have planned no budget for enforcement. Gee, that seems like code for, “We will use it to bust people when we need something to pull out of our pockets and selectively bust some but not all.”
As someone who picks up litter DAILY while walking the dogs (we are out anyway, and with the short-legged corgi pals we move at a snail’s pace, so why not?) it is a toss-up between candy wrappers and cigarette butt for the biggest nuisance award. HUGE fines for littering would be great, there isn’t a scenario in which the most freedom-loving of us has the RIGHT to dump our trash for others to deal with. And don’t get me started on gutters, between the fast food bags people have clearly just dumped from cleaning their car and not bothering with a trash can, and the “advertising” people who walk up and down streets putting flyers or business cards on windshields, folks go out to their car, pull the ad off the windshield. and for whatever reason believe the STREET is where that ad needs to go! WHAT IS WRONG WITH PEOPLE?
Crime experts now say they can predict an area’s crime rates using Google street view, judging things like trash/litter visible on lawns, alleyways, streets, parks, abandoned furniture, etc. People too busy or preoccupied to pick up litter are equally as unlikely to call the Police if they see something unusual.
If we are after trash, then let’s go after trash. Huge punitive fines for littering would put an end to a lot of it (if we could catch them) and if we are after healthy air, Anaheim has far, far worse pollutants than second hand smoke in open space. But if we are going to keep using bogus excuses like anti-smoking policies, anti-camping ordinances so vague one can be busted for “camping” simply for SITTING IN THE PARK if the officer believes you to be homeless, and dog parks as cover for scraping tent cities, then let’s come out and admit that what we are doing is making life so miserable for those without resources that they go somewhere else and stop being “Anaheim’s problem.” If that is a worthy endeavor, then let’s just go ahead and own it. but let’s stop hiding behind ridiculous policies trying to hide a lack of compassion, both for the homeless we have failed to provide for, and lack of compassion for the HOMEOWNERS forced to deal with the fallout of City Hall’s failure to come up with a real solution.
This inane proposal lacks an ounce of common sense and fails to address smoking or litter.
While I wholeheartedly agree with you on the littering issue (it drives me insane that people have a lack of courtesy and respect), I disagree on the smoking issue. Parks are a place for kids and families to visit and smoking is not conducive to that. Why should kids be forced to smell cigarette smoke? Why should, they, as well as other residents, be forced to smell the continuous smell of weed from the pot smokers at the park?
West Anaheim asked for this because of the proliferation of drugs and crime at the park. I wouldn’t even call them homeless as they’re the criminal element. Outreach is there every week to try and help them and guess what you find an hour later? The park littered in the very outreach pamphlets that our taxpayers foot the bill for!
Second, if you lived near any park in West Anaheim, you’d know there’s a significant criminal transient population at Reid, Maxwell, Peter Marshall- and there are many other hot spots like Lincoln and Knott that are an utter abomination. It’s only after residents complained that we received more police presence.
Further, the shelter is a very small piece of the puzzle. It will assist those that need and accept help, but the element out this way doesn’t want the help. What’s our solution (or the ACLU’s) to that?